CEO reflecting in the office

When business gets personal: How CEO personality shapes decisions

New research links CEO personality to diversification into unrelated businesses and pay arrangements that may favor executives over shareholders.

By Seb Murray

Ahead of Boss's Day, a new study suggests there may be more to leadership decisions than strategy and incentives — personality matters, too.

A CEO's personality may help explain whether they prioritize their own interests or those of shareholders, according to Don Lange, a professor of management and entrepreneurship and coauthor of a new study on CEO personality and corporate governance.

In the study, higher CEO scores on agreeableness and conscientiousness were associated with lower levels of unrelated diversification and a tighter link between CEO pay and company performance — two indicators the researchers used to examine potential CEO self-interest. Higher CEO neuroticism scores were linked to one of those indicators: firms with higher levels of unrelated diversification.

The findings, published in Strategic Management Journal, address a long-standing question in corporate governance: When do CEOs act in their own interests rather than those of shareholders?

The research draws on agency theory, which holds that the interests of executives and shareholders do not always align.

"Agency theory starts from the assumption that CEOs may act in their own interests unless boards put governance structures in place to keep that from happening. But that ignores that people are different," Lange says. "We know that when people have the chance to take advantage of a situation for their own gain, some will, and some won't. Personalities differ."

For 50 years, agency theory — popularized in a landmark 1976 paper by economists Michael Jensen and William Meckling — has shaped thinking about corporate governance. The new study brings a personality lens to that discussion, asking whether personality traits help explain why some CEOs are more likely than others to serve their own interests. Its authors are Zeyu Zhao, a former PhD student who is now an assistant professor at the Chinese University of Hong Kong; Xiwei Yi, an associate professor at Peking University's Guanghua School of Management; and Lange.

Personality shapes strategy

Firms led by CEOs who scored higher on agreeableness tended to be less diversified across unrelated lines of business: a one-standard-deviation increase in agreeableness was associated with about a 6% reduction in unrelated diversification. Such diversification has long been viewed as a potential drag on shareholder value, even as CEOs may benefit from more stable earnings, reduced career risk, and the prestige and control associated with overseeing a broader corporate portfolio.

Firms led by CEOs who scored higher on conscientiousness showed a similar pattern: a one-standard-deviation increase in the trait was associated with about a 3% reduction in unrelated diversification. The pattern was reversed for neuroticism: a one-standard-deviation increase was associated with about a 4% higher level of unrelated diversification, suggesting that firms led by CEOs higher on the trait tended to have broader portfolios of unrelated businesses.

Personality shapes pay, too

Agreeableness and conscientiousness were also associated with the extent to which CEO pay tracked company performance. CEOs higher in agreeableness and conscientiousness had compensation that was more closely tied to business results.

For a one-standard-deviation increase in company performance, CEO compensation was estimated to increase by about 16% when CEOs scored higher on conscientiousness, compared with about 11% when they scored lower on that trait. That suggests pay was more tightly coupled with performance for more conscientious CEOs. A similar pattern emerged for agreeableness: The same increase in firm performance was associated with about a 16% increase in compensation for CEOs who were higher in agreeableness, compared with 11% for those who were lower on that trait.

Rather than relying on personality questionnaires, the researchers used an open-language machine learning program to analyze CEOs' remarks during earnings calls and assess their "Big Five" personality traits: agreeableness, conscientiousness, neuroticism, extraversion, and openness.

The findings draw on data from S&P 1500 companies between 2002 and 2015. The final samples included more than 1,600 CEOs for the diversification analysis and more than 1,700 CEOs for the compensation analysis.

Not every prediction was supported. Higher neuroticism was associated with higher levels of unrelated diversification but was not significantly related to the extent to which CEO pay tracked company performance.

"Every study can be built on. We're measuring personality indirectly and using two indicators to infer self-serving behavior. They're good indicators, but they’re not perfect," Lange says.

Rethinking CEO selection

For boards, the findings point to another way of addressing potential CEO self-interest: considering personality when selecting a CEO.

"Boards have a dual role: to advise and to monitor," Lange says. "The more they focus on keeping CEOs in check, the less they can focus on helping them succeed. So don't treat CEOs as if they're all the same. Look for leaders with the traits and inclination to serve others."

Lange sees potential implications beyond the corner office. "The same patterns we found at the top of organizations are likely to exist throughout them," he says. "Different people are more or less likely to take advantage of systems and find loopholes. A smart leader recognizes those differences and hires accordingly."

Latest news